University of Hertfordshire

What are cultures?

University of Hertfordshire Research Archive

Help | UH Research Archive

Show simple item record

contributor authorLarvor, Brendan
contributor editorJu, S.
contributor editorLöwe, B.
contributor editorMüller, Th.
contributor editorXie, Y.
date accessioned2018-04-12T15:01:55Z
date available2018-04-12T15:01:55Z
date issued2016-08-10
identifier citationLarvor , B 2016 , What are cultures? in S Ju , B Löwe , T Müller & Y Xie (eds) , Cultures of Mathematics and Logic : Selected Papers from the Conference in Guangzhou, China, 9-12 November 2012 . Trends in the History of Science , Birkhauser Verlag Basel , Switzerland , pp. 1-22 . DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-31502-7en
identifier isbn978-3-319-31500-3
identifier isbn978-3-319-31502-7
identifier issn2297-2951
identifier otherPURE: 10017342
identifier otherPURE UUID: bc9a123a-3f63-41e8-bc54-7dbcaf0d296f
identifier otherScopus: 84963593767
identifier uri
identifier uri
description abstractIn this paper, I will argue for two claims. First, there is no commonly agreed, unproblematic conception of culture for students of mathematical practices to use. Rather, there are many imperfect candidates. One reason for this diversity is there is a tension between the material and ideal aspects of culture that different conceptions manage in different ways. Second, normativity is unavoidable, even in those studies that attempt to use resolutely descriptive, value-neutral conceptions of culture. This is because our interest as researchers into mathematical practices is in the study of successful mathematical practices (or, in the case of mathematical education, practices that ought to be successful). I first distinguish normative conceptions of culture from descriptive or scientific conceptions. Having suggested that this distinction is in general unstable, I then consider the special case of mathematics. I take a cursory overview of the field of study of mathematical cultures, and suggest that it is less well developed than the number of books and conferences with the word ‘culture’ in their titles might suggest. Finally, I turn to two theorists of culture whose models have gained some traction in mathematics education: Gert Hofstede and Alan Bishop. Analysis of these two models corroborates (in so far as two instances can) the general claims of this paper that there is no escaping normativity in this field, and that there is no unproblematic conception of culture available for students of mathematical practices to use.en
format extent22en
language isoeng
publisherBirkhauser Verlag Basel
relation ispartofCultures of Mathematics and Logicen
relation ispartofseriesTrends in the History of Scienceen
titleWhat are cultures?en
typeBook chapteren
contributor institutionSchool of Humanitiesen
contributor institutionPhilosophyen
identifier doi

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Your requested file is now available for download. You may start your download by selecting the following link: test